PLAGIO

sonic buzzard escribió:

psycho-sonic escribió:

Killing Joke: "Eighties" (1984)




Nirvana: "Come as you are" (1992)

Hostia que bueno!

sonic buzzard escribió:

psycho-sonic escribió:

Killing Joke: "Eighties" (1984)




Nirvana: "Come as you are" (1992)

Hostia que bueno!

The song "Come as You Are", by American grunge band Nirvana, has a riff similar to "Eighties." Nirvana and its management were unsure about releasing the song as a single from their 1991 studio album, Nevermind. Danny Goldberg, head of Nirvana's management Gold Mountain, later revealed that "[w]e couldn't decide between 'Come as You Are' and 'In Bloom.' Kurt [Cobain] was nervous about 'Come as You Are' because it was too similar to a Killing Joke song . . . but we all thought it was still the better song to go with. And, he was right, Killing Joke later did complain about it."[5] Nirvana biographer Everett True writes that "Come as You Are" was eventually chosen for release as a single because "Goldberg favoured the more obviously commercial song".

After Nirvana released the single in 1992, members of Killing Joke claimed the main guitar riff of "Come as You Are" plagiarized the riff of "Eighties", but according to Rolling Stone magazine, they did not file a copyright infringement lawsuit, because of "personal and financial reasons".[5] However, conflicting reports, such as Kerrang!, have stated differently.

Cobain's death in 1994 effectively dissolved Nirvana and the conflict with Killing Joke.[6] If there was a lawsuit issued that Kerrang! claimed, it was either thrown out of court,[7] or it was dropped to take the burden off the remaining members of Nirvana and their management. However, the court that supposedly took the case was not named and many doubted that Killing Joke ever issued a lawsuit against Nirvana.[8]

An interview with Geordie Walker that same year[9] reassured the possibility of a said lawsuit, thus proving that the claim by Kerrang! was not a hoax. Walker stated:
“ We were very pissed off about that, but it's obvious to everyone. We had two separate musicologists' reports saying it was. Our publisher sent their publisher a letter saying it was and they went 'Boo, never heard of ya!', but the hysterical thing about Nirvana saying they'd never heard of us was that they'd already sent us a Christmas card! ”


Nine years later, in 2003, Dave Grohl, Nirvana's drummer, took a leave of absence from his current band, the Foo Fighters, to record on drums for Killing Joke's second self-titled album. The move surprised some Nirvana fans, given Nirvana's past conflict with Killing Joke.

Bill Janovitz, writer for the website Allmusic, reviewed "Eighties". He compared and contrasted "Come as You Are" and "Eighties":[3]
“ While 'Eighties' unflinchingly displays the band's aggressive punk rock roots — cold and hard to mirror the socio-political message — it also embraces dance-music grooves and a certain sort of melodic sensibility. One main, perhaps, crucial difference between the bands is that while Kurt Cobain practiced whisper-to-a-scream vocal dynamics, Killing Joke's Jaz Coleman was almost always full-on in his approach, with a terrifying growl of a voice that is similar to that of Motörhead's Lemmy. ”


However, The Big Takeover magazine's Jack Rabid reported that Captain Sensible's "Life Goes On", recorded by The Damned for their 1982 album, Strawberries, "features the exact same, extremely unique riff as both 'Eighties' and 'Come as You Are'."[10] Jaz Coleman and Paul Ferguson have separately claimed to have no knowledge of this.[4][10]

helterstalker escribió:Los diez primeros segundos de When The Levee Breaks de Led Zeppelin= Bullet The Blue Sky entero de U2

Perimaggot escribió:aquí tienen ustedes a...

LA CHICA DE AYER, nota por nota



1976... qué cosas, oigan...

psycho-sonic escribió:

Killing Joke: "Eighties" (1984)




Nirvana: "Come as you are" (1992)

Perimaggot escribió:

Perimaggot escribió:aquí tienen ustedes a...

LA CHICA DE AYER, nota por nota



1976... qué cosas, oigan...

que a su vez era una versión de



1975...

vaya tela...

sonic buzzard VI+VII escribió:

Perimaggot escribió:

Perimaggot escribió:aquí tienen ustedes a...

LA CHICA DE AYER, nota por nota



1976... qué cosas, oigan...

que a su vez era una versión de



1975...

vaya tela...

Joder

Perimaggot escribió:

sonic buzzard VI+VII escribió:

Perimaggot escribió:

Perimaggot escribió:aquí tienen ustedes a...

LA CHICA DE AYER, nota por nota



1976... qué cosas, oigan...

que a su vez era una versión de



1975...

vaya tela...

Joder

es fuerte, eh

elDani escribió:

Perimaggot escribió:

sonic buzzard VI+VII escribió:

Perimaggot escribió:

Perimaggot escribió:aquí tienen ustedes a...

LA CHICA DE AYER, nota por nota



1976... qué cosas, oigan...

que a su vez era una versión de



1975...

vaya tela...

Joder

es fuerte, eh

¿La tan cacareada mejor canción pop de la historia es un vulgar plagio?

Eric Sachs escribió:bueno vamos a dar cera a dos de los hypes favoritos del foro :barbaro:
:

RickMahorn escribió:

CROWES escribió:

RickMahorn escribió:

Pero qué grande!!!!

Dan Defensor escribió:"Roll With It" de Oasis siempre me pareció un plagio de "Shady Lady" de Uriah Heep.

ion escribió:No se si ha salido ya, me da pereza repasar el post, pero es TAN descarado...

Zulander escribió:http://www.jotdown.es/2012/11/los-20-plagios-musicales-mas-sangrantes-del-siglo-xx/

Johnny Kashmir escribió:

Dejo que le saquéis las relaciones vosotros. Yo veo 4 claras.